Apr 17 2009

New “I’m a PC” commercials, Not enough reason to buy a PC Laptop

Category: Generalllabree @ 8:52 am

Let me preface this by saying I’ve used Macs and PCs for a long time, I know both systems very well, this is my advice on things to consider when spending your hard earned money on a new computer.

I assume you’ve seen the commercials (I’ve included one below) that Microsoft has released in response to the successful “I’m a Mac” ads…  They’re not bad, attempting to counter the impact that Apple has had with their spots.  The thing is though, they’re misleading people into thinking that setteling on a low price PC laptop is a good value.  It’s not.  A cheap PC is just that, cheap, and you get what you pay for.  The hardware used in the inside is different across PCs, and can be made of inferior, older or slower parts in order to lower the price.

Look at more than price and a number when you buy a new computer, components and capability are just as important.  Things to take into consideration along with the boldly advertised ram size and processor speed are graphics card and video performance, processor level, and security (antivirus software is not security, an operating system based on Unix that doesn’t need antivirus software is security.)

Then there’s build quality.  Macs have higher resale values than their counterparts, they’re well engineered and made to last.  Take a look at this; apple laptop survives plane crash.  The body of the new Macbooks are carved out of a single piece of aluminum, making them lighter, stronger and sleeker.  PC laptops are made from many, mostly plastic, parts.  Macs include slot loading DVD drives, compare that to the flimsy DVD trays on the average PC laptop.  Apple is innovative in their approach and meticulous in their detail, making their products a pleasure to own.

Consider software.  iLife alone, included free, adds hundreds of dollars worth of functionality to your investment.  Do the math on comparable software for a PC, it’s a lot money and it’s no where near as well made or as nicely integrated.  On a Mac you get software to edit movies, create DVDs, manage photos and music, a complete music creation suite, and a website creator.  On a PC you get chintzy manufacturer supplied software and worthless demo software or bloatware.

Finally, there’s the operating system, personally for me there’s no comparison OSX is better than Windows Vista or XP, here’s a pretty detailed comparison by InformationWeek (it’s very techie but if you really want to get a deeper understanding give it a read, otherwise just take my word for it.)

My suggestion: Get a Mac.

This is one of the Microsoft commercials currently running.

Below is a pretty funny “alternate”‘ version released online.

“Alternate” version

Update

Advertising Age reports that Microsoft has quietly altered at least one of its “Laptop Hunters” television commercials to remove reference to the price of a MacBook Pro after recent price cuts to Apple’s notebook line rendered the reference inaccurate. The move comes just a week after Microsoft’s Chief Operating Officer seemingly gloated over Apple’s lawyers having contacted Microsoft to request that the company address the inaccuracy.

In the 60-second spot, called “Lauren and Sue,” we watch as law student Lauren shops around with the help of her Mom in the hopes of finding a computer under $1,700.

In the original version, Lauren at one point comes upon an Apple computer and declares: “This Mac is $2,000, and that’s before adding anything.”

“Why would you pay twice the price?” asks Lauren’s mom. “I wouldn’t,” says Lauren, who ends up leaving with a $972 Dell laptop.

In the latest version of the ad, that portion has been edited out. The original ad has been removed from YouTube and other sites by Microsoft, and replaced with a version in which Lauren doesn’t talk about how much the Mac costs, but she does say: “It seems like you’re paying a lot for the brand.”

Microsoft is quick to point out that the focus of the ad remains unchanged.

“We slightly adjusted the ads to reflect the updated pricing of the Mac laptop shown in the TV advertisement,” a Microsoft spokeswoman said in a statement. “This does not change the focus of the campaign, which is to showcase the value and choice of the PC.”

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


Nov 20 2008

Gadget Lust Leads to Digression

Category: Generalllabree @ 12:43 pm

I want this computer.

The Dell Inspiron Mini 12

Out of the available netbooks out there, this seems like a solid machine, better suited to run Ubuntu than Vista, like it’s sibling the smaller Mini 9.

Learn more about it at the Dell website.

Sure.  I’m a Mac fan, I recommend that the average user buy them; for any application or use.  I’m also a fan of Ubuntu (Linux).  I’ve been experimenting with Linux for a long time, but only really started to consider it a viable everyday OS.  There have been many “consumer ready” version of Linux available.  Red Hat, YellowDog and Suse to name a few.  Not to mention Walmart, hocking budget computers running a Linux system for the last few years.

Ubuntu, or Linux in general is a secure, stable and surprisingly compatible operating system, and an open source one at that.  Open source meaning, the majority of the software you use, MS Office, Photoshop, iTunes, your digital camera software and endless other programs have free counterparts available, and often pre-installed with Ubuntu.  So instead of MS Office there’s OpenOffice, instead of Photoshop there’s GIMP.  If there’s software you need, the first place to check is a built in option, automatically updated from the internet, from which you can choose from dozens and dozens of categorized-for-your-convenience programs.  Ready to install with a click.

Ubuntu is an OS than can compete.  It’s current drawback, mass appeal and market availability.  Commercial organizations are just starting to develop software to work with Linux.  One of the things that makes Linux great, the number of different versions available, also makes it hard for developers to concentrate their focus.  This means that Made-for-PC game you just got won’t run on your linux computer.  Bright side, with a little Google research and some computer know-how you can make your Linux computer run anything, really.  

Do you want a laptop “just because”?

For anyone that already has a desktop computer, “full time” laptop or other computer setup, and is looking into a laptop; to use on the couch, take in the car, show picture slideshows, play games and read the news while watching tv, getting recipes on while cooking in the kitchen, using facebook while pooping, or carrying around and saying “hey, check this out” to your friends… are best of considering an Ubuntu or Linux based laptop / netbook.  They’re inexpensive, increasingly popular, and depending on your manufacturer pretty rugged and often upgradeable.

Out of the available netbooks out there, this seems like a solid machine, better suited to run Ubuntu than Vista, like it’s sibling the smaller Mini 9.  If it cost $100 less and ran Ubuntu I would buy it.  Give me a computer like this for $299-$399 and I’ll show you a booming netbook market.

But what do people really want in any computer?

People want the internet.  They want their music and movies.  They want their photos and blogs.  They want the ability to run things that others create.  And they want all that available now, ready, easy, fast and connected to everything.  They don’t want it to slow down or need updates.  They don’t want it freeze or even need to turn off.  They want it to be there, ready to preform these duties without hassle.

So you may wonder.  Where is all this leading?  I’ll tell you, but you probably won’t believe me.  But do believe me, because I’m right.  Tablets.  Tablets in the mainstream.  And I’m not talking about those stupid laptops with the funky flip-around screens either, real multi-touch tablets. Many things in the laptop and smart-phone ecosystem are pointing in this direction.  But that’s a digression for another time.

Here’s a mock-up of what I’m talking about.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Sep 23 2008

New Microsoft Commercials

Category: Generalllabree @ 6:56 am

I’m sure you’ve seen them on TV, the new Microsoft ads, being the Apple pundit that I am I thought I’d offer my 2 cents. Overall I like the MS commercials, there’s a lot of sentiment on the web going both directions, most of which seems to be negative. I like the Seinfeld ones more than the I’m a PC ones, they were funny if nothing else. Who really cares about the message or lack thereof, Gates is an icon, even if you look at just the end of the spot, where he did the robot in the street, and consider the unconscious impact it will have on most people the next time they’re in Best Buy, they’ll be distracted from their ‘Vista sucks’ conditioning by the image of Gates doing the robot – laugh to themselves and say ‘Silly Bill… Windows isn’t so bad’. I think MS would have done well pursuing the Seinfeld / Gates team up.

Tags: , , , , , , ,